comparative case study on botswana and somalia

• High School
• You don't have any recent items yet.
• You don't have any courses yet.
• You don't have any books yet.
• You don't have any Studylists yet.
• Information

Comparative Case Study on Botswana and Somalia

Ab political science (pos111), western mindanao state university, students also viewed.

• Procedure and Professional Ethics
• Political Theory assignment
• CS Form No. 4 Certification of Assumption to Duty
• CAPA FLAG Lowering - Copy
• Socialism reviewer - Summary AB Political Science
• 2015 SALN Form - Statement of assets

Related documents

• Exercise on Variation-Finding
• 264595704 Mga Teoryang Pampanitikan
• IATF-Resolution-No - About resolution
• IATF-Resolution-No - Resolution
• Constitutional LAW case 1
• Par Q Plus 2024 pdf - Files

Preview text

Botswana and Somalia are two African countries that have experienced very different political and economic outcomes despite having some geographic and historical similarities. A comparative case study of these two countries can help us understand the factors that influence the development and stability of states in Africa and beyond. Some of the similarities between Botswana and Somalia are:

Both are landlocked countries in Africa, with Botswana in the south and Somalia in the east.

Both have a long history of human civilization dating back to ancient times, with evidence of tools, cave drawings, and farming practices.

Both were colonized by European powers in the 19th and 20th centuries, with Botswana under British rule and Somalia under Italian and British rule.

Both gained independence in the 1960s, with Botswana in 1966 and Somalia in 1960. Some of the differences between Botswana and Somalia are:

Botswana has a stable parliamentary republic with a multi-party system, while Somalia has a fragile federal parliamentary republic with a clan-based system.

Botswana has a high level of political capacity, meaning it can effectively implement policies and provide public goods and services, while Somalia has a low level of political capacity, meaning it struggles to maintain order and security.

Botswana has a market-oriented economy that is based on diamond mining, tourism, and agriculture, while Somalia has a subsistence economy that is based on livestock, remittances, and informal trade.

Botswana has a high human development index (HDI) of 0, ranking 97th in the world, while Somalia has a low HDI of 0, ranking 194th in the world¹. Some of the possible explanations for these differences are:

Botswana had a more favorable colonial legacy than Somalia, as it was able to retain its traditional institutions and leaders, negotiate its independence peacefully, and avoid major conflicts with its neighbors².

Botswana had a more visionary and democratic leadership than Somalia, as it was led by Sir Seretse Khama, who promoted national unity, economic development, and good governance³. Somalia was led by Siad Barre, who imposed a military dictatorship, suppressed opposition, and provoked civil war⁴.

Botswana had a more prudent and transparent management of its natural resources than Somalia, as it used its diamond revenues to invest in education, health, and infrastructure⁵. Somalia had a more predatory and corrupt exploitation of its natural resources, as it suffered from resource curse, clan rivalry, and foreign intervention⁶. A comparative case study of Botswana and Somalia can reveal the importance of historical context, political institutions, leadership quality, and resource management for state development and stability. It can also show the challenges and opportunities for foreign aid in Africa, as both countries have received different amounts and types of aid from various donors. Source: Conversation with Bing, 10/10/ (1) 3: Comparative Case Study - Botswana and Somalia. socialsci.libretexts/Bookshelves/Political_Science_and_Civics/Introduction_to_Comparative_ Government_and_Politics_%28Bozonelos_et_al. %29/03%3A_States_and_Regimes/3%3A_Comparative_Case_Study_-_Botswana_and_Somalia. (2) THE IMPACT OF FOREIGN AID IN AFRICA: A CASE STUDY OF BOTSWANA AND SOMALIA. luc/media/lucedu/prolaw/documents/volume-5/2020%20PROLAW%20Journal %20Mary%20Izobo. (3) The Impact of Foreign Aid in Africa: A case study of Botswana and Somalia. academia/86723586/The_Impact_of_Foreign_Aid_in_Africa_A_case_study_of_Botswa na_and_Somalia. (4) The Impact of Foreign Aid in Africa: A case study of Botswana and Somalia. academia/80094499/The_Impact_of_Foreign_Aid_in_Africa_A_case_study_of_Botswa na_and_Somalia. (5) Leadership and ethnicity in the making of African state models .... library.fes/libalt/journals/swetsfulltext/11220689.pdf. (6) undefined. uu-.

• Multiple Choice

Course : AB Political Science (POS111)

University : western mindanao state university.

• More from: AB Political Science POS111 Western Mindanao State University 46   Documents Go to course